• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

The New Waverly of Otto: Authentic American Dining with Fresh Fish Fries & Family-Friendly Atmosphere

The New Waverly of Otto is a charming American restaurant nestled in rural Cattaraugus, NY, offering hearty, well-priced comfort food. Known for its standout Small Fish Fry, Ten Hot Wings with curly fries, and classic Fish and Chips, the menu brings simple, satisfying flavors to life with fresh, homemade sides. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, featuring friendly staff, clean spaces, and a touch of local character with country music and a jukebox. Though service can fluctuate, the quality and portion sizes impress, making it a beloved spot for families and travelers seeking good food without breaking the bank.

The New Waverly of Otto at a glance

  • Address 9125 Otto-E Otto Rd, Cattaraugus, NY 14719, United States
  • Phone +1 716-257-3443
  • Restaurant type American restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

The New Waverly of Otto: Reviews & Ratings

Nancy Gangloff
5

Food and service awesome! Wings huge. Sides with the fish fry homemade. French Onion soup loaded with onions and rich broth topped with lots of cheese. Prices very reasonable. We'll be back!!!

tammy lagowski
4

Waited no lie 20 mins just for the bartender to come give us a menu, waitress walked by at least a dozen times and never said anything to us. Fish was good and a nice size but way to many pickles in the tarter sauce. Salads were less then desirable. Lack of taste and not good at all. Going to try again to support the small business, hope it changes a bit. Prices were a little high however all fish fry are going up so that was to be expected.

Leah Guerin
4

Just started going to the new Waverly. We take our kids and granddaughter for dinner and will definitely go again. We have also been for date night for fish fries and drinks and recommend it for good food that won't kill your wallet. Its very clean with exceptionally friendly staff. I would recommend if your in the area, passing through or just looking for some good food.

Chris Ellis
5

Finally.made it. Nice little diner in the middle of nowhere. Food was good. The small fish is pretty small but was filling. Left some room for some cheap drinks. Pool table only costs 50cents. How nice is that. Could use a new house stick but they work. Bathrooms are nice and clean.

First Last
4

2022-09-09-Fri The first time my family and I tried this out-of-the-way Food and Drink Establishment. 5 out of the 6 of us chose from Friday's Fish selection and the other chose The 'Waverly' Burger. We all agreed our choices were especially fresh and delicious. The cost was inexpensive, especially considering the quality of the plates. The staff was courteous, professional & proficient. The décor was simple & the restaurant was clean & comfortable. As this is a very rural location, there is no Wi-Fi however country music is played and there is a jukebox available. My family and I will definitely be going back.

Teresa McWhirt
5

When we came up for a visit, I had the fish sandwich & it was delicious & that coleslaw was awesome. I'm looking forward to the wings this coming Wednesday. I can't wait

Keenan Tadt
5

We had an extremely large party, staff was excellent, food was good and everyone had a good time. My family now comes for wing nights!

Ron Minin
5

Fish dinner on Friday was just like old day. Freshly battered and a large portion. Customer service was awesome

Location

  • The New Waverly of Otto
    The New Waverly of Otto
    9125 Otto-E Otto Rd, Cattaraugus, NY 14719, United States Hotline: +1 716-257-3443

Located in the heart of Cattaraugus, NY, The New Waverly of Otto stands as a welcoming American eatery where comfort meets quality. This charming spot, nestled at 9125 Otto-E Otto Rd, is known for delivering hearty, home-style dishes without breaking the bank. The menu is anchored by standout items like the Small Fish Fry, Ten Hot Wings served with Curly Fries, and classic Fish and Chips—each crafted with care and served generously.

The Small Fish Fry, while modest in portion size as noted by some, remains a satisfying choice for those craving fresh, crispy seafood. The sides, particularly the homemade offerings accompanying the fish fry, set this spot apart. Customers praise the rich, cheese-topped French Onion soup for its depth of flavor and comforting warmth. Meanwhile, the Ten Hot Wings are a crowd favorite, noted for their large size and bold taste.

The New Waverly of Otto pairs its food with a friendly, down-to-earth atmosphere. Cleanliness and attentive service are commonly highlighted, creating a space ideal for family dinners or casual date nights. Despite a few critiques—such as wait times and certain dish details like the tartar sauce's pickle abundance—the overall sentiment is one of satisfaction and appreciation. Patrons value the balance of quality, portion, and price, making it a reliable stop in this quiet part of New York.

Beyond food, the restaurant offers simple pleasures like a jukebox playing country tunes and a budget-friendly pool table, enhancing its cozy, small-town charm. For those passing through or locals seeking genuine American fare with a touch of home comfort, The New Waverly of Otto delivers an authentic dining experience worth exploring.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards